On the coherence of supremum preserving upper previsions
نویسندگان
چکیده
We study the relation between possibility measures and the theory of imprecise probabilities. It is shown that a possibility measure is a coherent upper probability iff it is normal. We also prove that a possibility measure is the restriction to events of the natural extension of a special kind of upper probability, defined on a class of nested sets. Next, we go from upper probabilities to upper previsions. We show that if a coherent upper prevision defined on the convex cone of all positive gambles is supremum preserving, then it must take the form of a Shilkret integral associated with a possibility measure. But at the same time, we show that a supremum preserving upper prevision is not necessarily coherent! This makes us look for alternative extensions of possibility measures that are not necessarily supremum preserving, through natural extension.
منابع مشابه
Convex Imprecise Previsions: Basic Issues and Applications
In this paper we study two classes of imprecise previsions, which we termed convex and centered convex previsions, in the framework of Walley’s theory of imprecise previsions. We show that convex previsions are related with a concept of convex natural estension, which is useful in correcting a large class of inconsistent imprecise probability assessments. This class is characterised by a condit...
متن کاملSupremum Preserving Upper Probabilities
We study the relation between possibility measures and the theory of imprecise probabilities, and argue that possibility measures have an important part in this theory. It is shown that a possibility measure is a coherent upper probability if and only if it is normal. A detailed comparison is given between the possibilistic and natural extension of an upper probability, both in the general case...
متن کاملCoherent Upper and Lower Previsions
This is an introduction to the concepts of lower and upper prevision and the mathematical theory of coherence. Upper and lower previsions are generalisations of upper and lower probabilities. They can model a very wide variety of kinds of uncertainty, partial information and ignorance. The theory of coherent lower previsions is based on a simple behavioural interpretation of lower previsions. T...
متن کاملUncertainty modelling and conditioning with convex imprecise previsions
Two classes of imprecise previsions, which we termed convex and centered convex previsions, are studied in this paper in a framework close to Walley’s and Williams’ theory of imprecise previsions. We show that convex previsions are related with a concept of convex natural estension, which is useful in correcting a large class of inconsistent imprecise probability assessments, characterised by a...
متن کاملFull conglomerability, continuity and marginal extension
We investigate fully conglomerable coherent lower previsions in the sense of Walley, and some particular cases of interest: envelopes of fully conglomerable linear previsions, envelopes of countably additive linear previsions and fully disintegrable linear previsions. We study the connections with continuity and countable super-additivity, and show that full conglomerability can be characterise...
متن کامل